Unequal returns to university completion in the early career: Evidence from Australian administrative data
Please note - this presentation was updated 12 November, 2026. The title was previously "Understanding transitions from enabling programs to and through university"
While prior studies have established complex and heterogeneous effects of university education on mid-career outcomes, it remains unclear whether these patterns of heterogeneous effects are present during the early-career transition into the labor market. Using linked Australian population-level administrative data, we estimate treatment effects of bachelor’s degree completion on early-career earnings, occupational status, and labor market engagement for young men and women who enroll in university. We find significant positive effects of completion on average early-career earnings, occupational status, and labor market engagement. However, we find countervailing patterns for completion premiums earnings and occupational status. The most advantaged graduates experience the largest completion premium on earnings, but the smallest premium on occupation conditional on employment. This pattern emerges because dropouts from advantaged socioeconomic backgrounds with high prior academic achievement are less likely to be engaged in the labor market, even relative to more disadvantaged dropouts. Thus, advantaged non-completers have lower average earnings due to lower labor market engagement, but those who are engaged have relatively high-status occupations. The observed patterns also appear stronger for men than women. After restricting to those engaged in employment, treatment effects among the most advantaged students are substantially reduced. These findings, including more pronounced effects for advantaged men, are consistent with theories of occupational expectations and entitlements, where members of high-status groups do not revise expectations downward after receiving negative signals of their abilities or skills.